Skip to Content

All Rookie Ratings in Madden 23

See where your favorite team’s draft picks fall in the pecking order
Madden 23 screenshot
Image via EA Tiburon

Filling out a 53-man roster in Madden 23 can be a challenging task, to say the least. Obviously, you’ve got your mainstay cornerstone pieces of the franchise, but beyond that it’s an open competition for just about every position. Regardless of the team, you’re still likely to end up with at least one or two quality rookies primed to take over a game.

In this guide, we will break down all of the best rookie ratings in Madden 23.

All Rookie Ratings in Madden 23

Outside of being a first-round lottery pick, rookies rarely make an impact in their first year in the NFL. With so many players on a roster and various personnel packages, it’s easy for rookies to get forgotten about. Particularly if one or two names ahead of them come out of the gates swinging. That being said, this year’s batch of rookies has a solid blend of talent on offense and defense, so, you should be able to find value somewhere.

Related: All Relocation Teams in Madden 23 Franchise Mode

Without further ado, here’s a list of all the best rookie ratings in Madden 23;

  1. Jameson Williams, WR (78), Detroit Lions
  2. Jordan Davis, DT (78), Philadelphia Eagles
  3. Sauce Gardner, CB (78), New York Jets
  4. Aidan Hutchinson, LOLB (77), Detroit Lions
  5. Derek Stingley, CB (77), Houston Texans
  6. Evan Neal, RT (77), New York Giants
  7. Kenneth Walker, RB (77), Seattle Seahawks
  8. Garrett Wilson, WR (76), New York Jets
  9. Ikem Ekwonu, LT (76), Carolina Panthers
  10. Travon Walker, LOLB (76), Jacksonville Jaguars
  11. Breece Hall, RB (76), New York Jets
  12. Chris Olave, WR (76), New Orleans Saints
  13. Kyle Hamilton, SS (76), Baltimore Ravens
  14. Daxton Hill, FS (75), Cincinnati Bengals
  15. Drake London, WR (75), Atlanta Falcons
  16. Jahan Dotson, WR (75), Washington Commanders
  17. James Cook, RB (75), Buffalo Bills
  18. Kayvon Thibodeaux, ROLB (75), New York Giants
  19. Lewis Cine, FS (75), Minnesota Vikings
  20. George Karlaftis, LE (74), Kansas City Chiefs
  21. George Pickens, WR (74), Pittsburgh Steelers
  22. Jermaine Johnson II, LE (74), New York Jets
  23. Matt Araiza, P (74), Buffalo Bills
  24. Tyler Linderbaum, C (74), Baltimore Ravens
  25. Andrew Booth Jr., CB (73), Minnesota Vikings
  26. Cade York, K (73), Cleveland Browns
  27. Charles Cross, LT (73), Seattle Seahawks
  28. Devonte Wyatt, RW (73), Green Bay Packers
  29. Isaiah Spiller, RB (73), Los Angeles Chargers
  30. Jake Camarda, P (73), Tampa Bay Buccaneers
  31. John Metchie III, WR (73), Houston Texans
  32. Kaiier Elam, CB (73), Buffalo Bills
  33. Quay Walker, MLB (73), Green Bay Packers
  34. Trey McBride, TE (73), Arizona Cardinals
  35. Treylon Burks, WR (73), Tennessee Titans
  36. Dameon Pierce, RB (72), Houston Texans
  37. Kenyon Green, LG (72), Houston Texans
  38. Skyy Moore, WR (72), Kansas City Chiefs
  39. Trevor Penning, LT (72), New Orleans Saints
  40. Wan’Dale Robinson, WR (72), New York Giants
  41. Christian Watson, WR (71), Green Bay Packers
  42. Kyler Gordon, CB (71), Chicago Bears
  43. Nakobe Dean, MLB (71), Philadelphia Eagles
  44. Tyrion Davis-Price, RB (71), San Francisco 49ers
  45. Cam Taylor-Britt, CB (70), Cincinnati Bengals
  46. Chad Muma, MLB (70), Jacksonville Jaguars
  47. Cole Strange, RB (70), New England Patriots
  48. Desmond Ridder, QB (70), Atlanta Falcons
  49. Khalil Shakir, WR (70), Buffalo Bills
  50. Rachaad White, RB (70), Tampa Bay Buccaneers

That’s everything you need to know about all of the best rookie ratings in Madden 23. If you’re interested in more Madden content, be sure to check out our guides section here at Gamer Journalist. Where you can find information like how to create a custom roster in Madden 23 or all Madden 23 player motivations and tags.

Back to Navigation