How to Complete All Stewards Challenges in Good Pizza, Great Pizza

In Chapter 2 of Good Pizza, Great Pizza, you will have an exciting opportunity to meet Stewards of Sacred Ingredients, a six-member secret society. These guys will visit your shop from time to time to test you and will award you with new ingredients each time you’re successful in completing their orders.

Having in mind that you have us as your assistants, you’re bound to reap all of those rewards like it was nothing! Follow our detailed guide, and no Steward will cause you trouble!

Related: All Recipes in Good Pizza, Great Pizza

Recipes for All Steward Challenges in Good Pizza, Great Pizza

The first Steward encounter introduces you to the gang: three guys, two women, and a goat. Later, they will proceed to come one by one and have peculiar and unusual requests to test your baking skills. With the first challenge, the group will ask you to make 3 pizzas – “One plain. One Vegetarian. One with meat.” Here are the recipes:

• Plain pizza – Sauce and Cheese.
• Vegetarian pizza – Sauce, Cheese, Olive, Mushroom, Onion, Eggplant, and Bell Pepper.
• Meat pizza – Sauce, Cheese, Pepperoni, and Sausage.

The following Steward challenges can come in a different order but will have the same requests for their pizzas. Follow up with our recipes below to make the ideal pizza for every Steward.

Destiny Steward (Younger Lady Steward Order 1st Time)

After you’ve been visited by the full lineup of the secret society, you’ll have a first solo visit by the young lady from the squad. She will ask you to make her a pizza that “reveals your destiny” which basically means that you can make whichever pizza you want. It’s the easiest challenge of them all so use your imagination!

Basil Steward (Younger Lady Steward Order 2nd Time)

When this Steward approaches you again, she will ask for a pizza of peace with “ingredients that grow in the ground and those that hang above the soil” while telling you that she hates pineapples. The pizza she wishes for is half and half and needs Cheese and Sauce as a base. On one side, add Mushroom and Onion, and on the other side, put Bell Pepper, Olive, and Basil.

Wheat Steward (Goat Steward Order)

This Steward isn’t so talkative, as you will soon notice, and the only information he will utter is “…”. No worries, though, as we got your back with this order as well.

When Goat asks you for a pizza, you need to use Wheat dough and make classic Cheese pizza with Sauce and Cheese. This will complete another Steward challenge and make the hop off in a happy tone.

Anchovy Steward (Mustache Guy Steward Order)

The mustache guy will order pizza in a seemingly threatening way, saying that “there’s something fishy about you.” When asked to clarify, he will tell you that he wants to see a deserted beach pizza, with “fish swimming in the sea and not a soul on the sand.”

For this Steward, you need to make a pizza that will have Sauce and Anchovy on the one side and literally nothing on the other side. Even though the order sounds a bit weird, the solution to this one is actually quite fun and makes perfect sense, considering what he said.

Pork Steward (Old Lady Steward Order)

The old lady Steward will walk into your pizza shop asking for “a mighty meat pie.” As she notes, “Keep quadrilateral meat to the one side; the other meats can straddle both sides. Pork only, partner”.

For the whole pizza, use Sauce, Cheese, Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bacon. Ham is the only quadrilateral meat you have, so it will be the only ingredient that you need to use on one-half of your pizza. Bake it, wrap it, and reap your reward for this one, master ovenist!

Pineapple Steward (Bald Steward Order)

The bald guy will come in talking in rhymes, so you really need to be creative to pick up on his order. He says that he wants a sweet pizza and then clarifies it with “All the fruit; hold the meat, not even cheese, but don’t put it on wheat”. To bake his pizza, you need to use Sauce, Bell Pepper, Olive, Eggplant, and Pineapple. This sweet thing will win you his reward.

Final Steward (Big Gray-haired Steward Order)

The final Steward arrives to acknowledge that you have “passed all the trials,” followed by a statement that if you’re the “chosen one,” you’ll know which pizza to make for him. Once again, you can make any pizza you want, so this last challenge shouldn’t be a stress for you!

Stewards don’t stand a chance with a guide like this! Learn more about Good Pizza, Great Pizza from our pieces Use These Upgrades if You Want Your Pizza Shop to Stand Out! and How to Complete Bonfyre Fest in Good Pizza, Great Pizza. You can also go on Facebook and follow Gamer Journalist so you are always up to date with the latest gaming news and guides.